Whenever a filmmaker breaks onto the scene with an impressive debut film, there is immense pressure to follow up their groundbreaking first movie with something equally good, if not better. Even if a director’s debut efforts isn’t a massive success straight out of the gate, there’s still a sense of wanting to go bigger for the second outing — bigger stories, bigger names in the cast, and bigger budgets. If the artists in question don’t deliver, they’re said to suffer a sophomore slump, which can be a devastating creative setback.
Fortunately, numerous directors’ second movies live up to their first, and this is especially true in the horror genre. From some of the biggest names working today — including Jordan Peele, Ari Aster, and Coralie Fargeat — to lesser-known but equally talented filmmakers quietly making stellar movies, these sophomore films prove their directors are no one-hit wonders. Each film successfully avoids the sophomore slump by not only going bigger in terms of story and scope, but also in terms of the scares and psychologically disturbing ideas.
10
Us (2019)
Directed By Jordan Peele
Jordan Peele’s feature directorial debut Get Out was an immediate hit upon its release, receiving great reviews from critics and horror fans alike. It’s one of the rare horror movies to receive Oscar nominations, including for best picture, best director, and best original screenplay — the latter of which it won. The pressure was certainly on Peele to create something of the same caliber as his first outing, so he takes some big swings with his follow-up, Us, and each one is a hit.
Peele’s scope is much wider in Us, examining not only race in America, but this country’s class structure as well. The subterranean doppelgängers of the film, called the Tethered, represent the underprivileged of the United States, and their bloody uprising serves as a warning to the privileged of the country — continue prospering off the backs of others, and there will be a reckoning. This bleaker messaging and the film’s haunting ending meant Us didn’t hit with the Oscars and was snubbed, but it was just as deserving of the accolades as Get Out.
9
Fear Street: Part One – 1994 (2021)
Directed By Leigh Janiak
5/10
- Release Date
-
July 2, 2021
- Runtime
-
105 minutes
- Director
-
Leigh Janiak
- Writers
-
Leigh Janiak, Phil Graziadei
Before Leigh Janiak struck it big with her trilogy of teen slasher films for Netflix, based on the works of R.L. Stine, the director made an effective psychological sci-fi horror film called Honeymoon. The slow-burner earned Janiak praise for her ability to ratchet up tension and sustain an atmosphere of dread throughout. Janiak takes her talent for horror to the next level with Fear Street: Part One – 1994, the highlight in the trilogy, and combines it with an often dark sense of humor.
Some viewers might be turned off at the notion of horror aimed at a teenage audience, but make no mistake, Fear Street does not skimp on the inventive and increasingly gory kills that define the slasher film. Unlike many movies in the subgenre, however, Fear Street takes its time letting the audience get to know its characters, making their deaths all the more devastating when they come. Janiak proves herself a highly talented storyteller, regardless of genre or the intended age of the audience.
8
Ready Or Not (2019)
Directed By Matt Bettinelli-Olpin & Tyler Gillett
8/10
- Release Date
-
August 21, 2019
- Runtime
-
95 minutes
- Director
-
Matt Bettinelli-Olpin, Tyler Gillett
- Writers
-
R. Christopher Murphy, Guy Busick
After breaking into the horror genre with numerous short films, including a memorable entry in the anthology film V/H/S, Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett — known alongside their production partners as Radio Silence — made their feature-length debut with Devil’s Due. The film mostly came and went, despite being a well-crafted combination of found footage and religious horror. Devil’s Due is an interesting first entry into the directors’ canon, however, because it lacks an overt sense of humor that characterizes Radio Silence’s other films.
Related
15 Movies To Watch If You Liked Ready Or Not
One of the best recent indie movies is Ready or Not. If you love horror and black comedy, check out these similar movies.
That would immediately change for Bettinelli-Olpin and Gillett’s follow-up feature Ready or Not, which is full of both thrills and darkly funny jokes. This emphasis on horror as well as comedy was the secret ingredient missing from the duo’s filmmaking recipe, and adding it to the mix for Ready or Not meant their second feature coalesces into a singular filmgoing experience better than Devil’s Due. While the filmmakers proved they could hold interest in a feature setting with their debut, they truly found their voice in Ready or Not, setting the tone for all their future works.
7
Oddity (2024)
Directed By Damian Mc Carthy
8/10
- Release Date
-
July 19, 2024
- Runtime
-
98 Minutes
- Director
-
Damien Mc Carthy
- Writers
-
Damian Mc Carthy
Damian Mc Carthy broke onto the horror scene in 2020 with his debut feature Caveat, an inventive take on the haunted house narrative. The film didn’t get a theatrical release, but it did land a spot on the horror movie streaming service Shudder, where it’s been quietly unnerving viewers ever since. Critics were mostly warm to Caveat as well, and anticipation was high as to what Mc Carthy would do next.
The director delivered and then some with his second film, Oddity, which centers around a large wooden statue that sits eerily at the dining table and possibly begins to move. An obvious nod to the Golem of Jewish folklore, the statue strikes a decidedly creepy figure, and it should be counted among the most effective objects-come-to-life in horror movies since the Zuni fetish doll from Trilogy of Terror, the titular car from Christine, or the cursed red dress from In Fabric.
6
Midsommar (2019)
Directed By Ari Aster
Hereditary, Ari Aster’s first film, proved to be a tough act to follow for the director, given the incredibly strong material and its popularity among filmgoers. For his second outing, Midsommar, Aster goes bigger, bolder, and even stranger than its predecessor, to remarkable effect. Containing less jump scares and directly horrific imagery than Hereditary, Midsommar is a much more contemplative and psychologically unsettling film built around a crumbling, toxic relationship, all set against a perversely colorful, sun-drenched backdrop.
Aster himself called Midsommar “The Wizard of Oz for perverts,” and the parallels between Dani and Dorothy’s journeys are immediately apparent, especially in comparison to the 1939 film adaptation. The narratives center on the absence of parents, as do so many fairy tales, with Dani’s tragic separation more in line with a Grimm story than Dorothy’s more innocent situation. Ultimately, both protagonists want to go home, but for Dani, there is no home to go back to, priming her to seek a new home and family with the Hårga.
5
Cuckoo (2024)
Directed By Tilman Singer
7/10
- Release Date
-
August 9, 2024
- Runtime
-
102 Minutes
- Director
-
Tilman Singer
- Writers
-
Tilman Singer
Tilman Singer made an impressive directorial debut with Luz, a super low-budget, brilliantly executed film that subverts the tropes of the possession narrative in interesting ways. For his second feature, Cuckoo, Singer pays homage to the works of David Cronenberg, in particular The Brood, with an absolutely bonkers plot delivered in a frenetic style. Featuring an incredible performance from Hunter Schafer as the film’s protagonist Gretchen, Cuckoo is quietly one of the best horror films of 2024.
Singer proves himself especially adept at sustaining weirdness throughout, a skill on full display with Luz, but with Cuckoo, it’s cranked to the max. Cuckoo is wild and unpredictable in its narrative turns, relying on a more dreamlike logic to tell its story. At times, it even plays out like a cartoon, with Dan Stevens playing the over-the-top mad scientist and primary foe of Gretchen with a glee that echoes kid’s animated fare. Cuckoo is altogether giddy in its execution, even in its most perverse moments, making it a truly unique viewing experience.
4
The Substance (2024)
Directed By Coralie Fargeat
10/10
- Release Date
-
September 20, 2024
- Runtime
-
140 Minutes
- Director
-
Coralie Fargeat
- Writers
-
Coralie Fargeat
-
Demi Moore
Elisabeth Sparkle
-
Coralie Fargeat made her debut in 2017 with the critically-acclaimed but criminally underseen film Revenge, an especially potent feminist take on the rape revenge fantasy film. Fargeat subverts the tropes of this subgenre first and foremost by not lingering on the assault itself — the mere existence of the act in the film is enough to horrify without showing it in detail. The film does emphasize the fantasy elements of the aftermath, creating a thoroughly formidable heroine in the process. Revenge is truly an audacious debut, and a tough act to follow.
Fargeat ups the ante with The Substance, creating a body horror satire that tackles society’s obsession with beauty and youth. With a career-high performance from Demi Moore and another impressive turn from Margaret Qualley, The Substance earned heaps of praise both for its stars and writer-director Fargeat. The film became another rare horror film to receive Oscar nominations, including for best picture, best director, and best actress for Moore. Fargeat more than proves herself a prominent voice in modern-day horror filmmaking, one who will no doubt continue to make subversive entries in the genre.
3
Titane (2021)
Directed By Julia Ducournau
5/10
- Release Date
-
October 1, 2021
- Runtime
-
108 minutes
- Director
-
Julia Ducournau
- Writers
-
Julia Ducournau
It’s certainly a badge of honor when a horror film can elicit visceral reactions from viewers, and that’s exactly what happened with Raw, the audacious directorial debut of Julia Ducournau. Filmgoers at a Toronto screening in 2016 passed out (via The Guardian) while watching the graphic cannibal-themed film, prompting the theater to call the paramedics. Beyond the intensity of the flesh-eating scenes, Ducournau crafts an endearing coming-of-age tale, one that won over numerous critics upon its release.
Related
10 Modern Horror Movies That Prove Body Horror Is Back
Body horror films are still alive and well in the modern era, with many movies earning their place in the increasingly popular subgenre.
There were no reports of viewers fainting during Ducournau’s second feature, the Palme d’Or-winning Titane, despite featuring one especially graphic scene early in the film, in which serial killer protagonist Alexia (Agathe Rousselle) has sex with a car. It’s the kind of unforgettably perverse imagery that will either engross or repel. For anyone too squeamish to continue, they’re missing out on one of the most inventive, psychologically potent body horror films since David Cronenberg’s magnificent works from the 1980s.
2
The Nightingale (2018)
Directed By Jennifer Kent
The Babadook marked one of the most stellar directorial debuts in cinema history, regardless of genre. With the titular monster, Jennifer Kent created a figure as iconic as Frankenstein’s creature or Freddy Kruger, as well as an unintentional symbol of gay pride. The film is also, for better and worse, one of the first in the so-called trend of “elevated horror,” a contentious term in the horror community describing films that trade less in jump scares and more in psychological dread and unease, usually with some kind of social commentary woven into the narrative’s fabric.
While the film was well-reviewed, The Nightingale was not the hit The Babadook was, no doubt because of its difficult-to-watch scenes and overall heavier tone.
Kent avoids the sophomore slump with her follow-up The Nightingale by nearly abandoning horror altogether, creating instead a revenge thriller based around the real-life horrors of sexual assault and colonization. While the film was well-reviewed, The Nightingale was not the hit The Babadook was, no doubt because of its difficult-to-watch scenes and overall heavier tone. This is a shame, as The Nightingale is beautifully crafted, emotionally satisfying, and one of the most important viewing experiences a filmgoer can have.
1
I Saw The TV Glow (2024)
Directed By Jane Schoenbrun
6/10
- Release Date
-
May 3, 2024
- Runtime
-
100 minutes
- Director
-
Jane Schoenbrun
- Writers
-
Jane Schoenbrun
- Producers
-
Emma Stone, Len Blavatnik, Dave McCary, Taylor Shung, Danny Cohen, Sarah Winshall, Ali Herting
A creator of low-fi horror movies, Jane Schoenbrun proved with their first feature, We’re All Going to the World’s Fair, that filmmakers don’t need a lot of money to create effective and engaging cinema. With a coming-of-age story that unfolds largely on webcams and computer screens, Schoenbrun makes tremendous use of very little, showcasing their knack for economic narratives and psychological unease. The film did well critically, establishing Schoenbrun as a distinct voice in filmmaking.
These talents would be on full display again with Schoenbrun’s follow-up I Saw the TV Glow, which features a bigger budget and wider distribution thanks to A24, but it’s just as spiritually independent as its predecessor. I Saw the TV Glow was met with great reviews upon its release, including from famed director Martin Scorsese, who called it “emotionally and psychologically powerful and very moving,” (via AP) quite an astute assessment of Schoenbrun’s triumphant work. I Saw the TV Glow isn’t just one of the best horror films of 2024, it’s one of the best films of the year, period.
Source: The Guardian, AP
