Cynthia Bailey Says Lenny Kravitz Never Called After He Got Her Number

Cynthia Bailey and Lenny Kravitz could’ve been an item! 

On Friday, Nov. 1, the Real Housewives of Atlanta star, 57, participated in a live taping of Teddi Mellencamp and Tamra Judge’s Two Ts in a Pod podcast at the iHeartRadio Theater in Burbank, Calif., where she revealed that the Grammy winner did not call her after obtaining her phone number. 

Bailey said that she met Kravitz, 60, at Mick Jagger’s star-studded 80th birthday party last July in London, where the rock legend introduced them to each other.

“I didn’t really feel any sparks,” the reality TV star admitted. 

Bailey continued to say that tried to play it “really cool” around Kravitz, given that she has “talked about him [for] the last five years.”

“He was really nice. He didn’t seem overly interested or anything,” she added, before detailing that Kravitz inquired about getting in touch with her.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

“He asked Mick’s fiancée for my number,” Bailey said, which prompted Mellencamp, 43, to ask: “But did he ask for anybody else’s number?”

“That I don’t know,” Bailey then replied, before joking, “Apparently so. He didn’t use my damn number.”

Last September, Bailey told PEOPLE In an exclusive interview that she met someone she was interested in romantically, though she said she was taking things slow following her separation from Fox Sports correspondent Mike Hill after their two years of marriage.

“It’s coming along all right, it’s coming along,” she said of her dating life at the time. “There’s someone that I really like dating a lot, but we’re taking it slow. I’m still open to dating other people.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Bailey filed for divorce from Hill in October 2022. She shared a statement with PEOPLE at the time that read, “God does not make mistakes! I truly believe in my heart Mike coming into my life was destiny. I jumped in, both feet first and gave it my all.”

“Although that journey has come to an end,” she added. “I am so grateful for our continued friendship, and the beautiful memories that we made together. God willing, I will find love again. Whatever is destined to be, will be; and I could not be more excited for my next chapter!”

The Real Housewives of Atlanta‘s season 16 is set to premiere in 2025.